Comparing the scally cap vs flat cap
At first glance, perhaps a scally cap and flat cap look quite similar. But take a minute to examine the two, and you’ll see quite a few differences.
In this blog post, we take a deep dive into the two styles of cap to give you a better understanding of what makes each unique. Plus, we give you some styling tips for integrating both caps into your wardrobe. Ready? Let’s compare scally caps vs flat caps.
Scally cap vs flat cap: What's the difference?
From their humble beginnings to their place in modern fashion, here are the main differences between a scally cap and a flat cap.
Their origin stories
The scally cap:
The scally cap originated in the United Kingdom and Ireland in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, commonly worn by working-class boys and young men. ‘Scally’ was northern English slang for a man with little education and often suspected of committing petty crimes.
Despite the working-class roots of the hat, they became a fashionable accessory among the upper class in the 1920s. Its popularity spread to the United States around this time, as many Irish settlers made their way across the Atlantic. Here, it became a staple among the working class, particularly in eastern cities like Boston.
The flat cap:
In contrast, the flat cap has a more refined history: it dates back to 14th century England and was initially worn by the aristocracy for hunting and outdoor activities. By the 16th century, it became more widespread due to a law requiring men to wear wool caps on Sundays, leading to its adoption among the general population. It remained a popular style through the centuries and is still a wardrobe essential for the modern gentleman.
Their structure
The scally cap:
The brim of the scally cap is short and stiff, typically sewn down to the body of the cap, which helps maintain its structured look. This design makes the scally cap sit higher on the head and gives it a more casual, rugged aesthetic.
The flat cap:
The flat cap's brim is also short and stiff, but it is usually not as prominent as the scally cap's brim. Instead, it extends just slightly beyond the front of the cap, for a more sophisticated and understated look.
Their shape atop the head
The scally cap:
Yes, scally caps and flat caps are quite similar, but the crown of a scally cap is slightly taller at the back. From the side, it almost looks like a triangle with three straight sides, while a flat cap retains its curve over the back of the head.
The flat cap:
A flat cap’s gentle curve over the head seamlessly integrates with the brim, looking more like a gentle wave when viewed side-on.
Their practical use
The general rule of thumb is that scally caps are great for casual and smart-casual occasions, while flat caps shine in semi-formal and formal settings.
The scally cap:
The scally cap is associated with casual, everyday wear, and pairs well with jeans, t-shirts, and casual jackets. It can be seen as a step up from a classic baseball cap. For a modern twist, try pairing it with a bomber jacket or a sweater for a comfortable, yet trendy look.
The flat cap:
The flat cap, on the other hand, has a more refined, sophisticated edge. Traditionally associated with country attire, the flat cap pairs well with tailored clothing, such as suits or tweed jackets. For a classic look, match the flat cap with a wool coat or a blazer. It also is a great way to step up a casual outfit, such as chinos and a button-down shirt, providing a touch of class.
Should I choose a scally cap or flat cap?
The main thing to note is that, despite their similar appearance, you don’t have to choose between a scally cap and a flat cap. Each has its place in your wardrobe and will enhance your outfits — it’s just about styling them appropriately.
For all your headwear needs, Tweedtopper has you covered. Explore our range of scally caps and flat caps to find the perfect one for you. Before ordering, be sure to read through our guide to measuring your head and determining the right cap size.
Our favorite scally caps
When choosing a scally cap, think about what clothing you already have in your wardrobe — the colors, materials, and occasions.
Gray blue herringbone
If your wardrobe features a lot of neutrals — blacks, whites, grays — then a classic gray-blue cap will be easy to incorporate into all of your outfits. The herringbone will add texture to even the simplest of outfits.
Green herringbone
Do you open your closet to see a lot of brown? This could be camel-colored sweaters, tan button-ups, or deep chocolate leather jackets. Then a forest green hat will become your new best friend.
Brown herringbone
If your wardrobe is a mix of styles, textures, and colors, opt for a simple neutral brown herringbone scally cap. The versatile cap can work across a variety of outfits, whether you’re heading to a ball game or birthday drinks.
All our scally caps are made with the finest 100% wool that will keep your head warm and your outfit stylish. Designed with a snug and comfortable fit, the polyester quilted lining feels great against your head, while the wool is durable and easy to maintain.